Christian convert freed

Dart

Moderator
http://www.nytimes.com/2006/03/28/international/asia/28afghan.html

What's everyone's thoughts on this?? A man converts from Islam to Christianity 16 years ago was found by police with a Bible and he is instantly thrown into prison and is almost executed before the UN steps in. As he leaves the prison, Islamic clerics are chanting "Death to Christians" in the streets.

My opinion is if they want Christians dead (that's what they call anyone who is from the West), then we should leave Afghanistan and let them kill eachother instead.
 
They kill Christians now? Oh man, this is actually a new bit of info for me :) I always considered they had issues with the Jews. Yet this, is quite weird...you think it's just because he converted that makes him hated by the Islamics?
 
Man that's nuts. I never knew that :( Well let's do what Jesus would do, set'em on fire and send them to hell! :)
 
Dray said:
religious governments aren't the best way to go
well... I have to agree... as a Christian, I want the seperation of chuch and state...

I know it's a different culture and all.... but that is crazy.


†B†V† :hat
 
Dray said:
religious governments aren't the best way to go

I agree. Theocratic governments are not always a great idea. Mainly because the ones in power tend to crave the power more than they want to obey their very own government.

As for radical Muslims hating Christians, that's been since day one that it's been that way. And that's no matter how much Muslims say that isn't true. I have a Quran, and it specifically states that Jews and christians are heretics and infdels, and that any infidel who does not convert to Islam must be put to death.

I have a bleeding heart for those who live in such conditions, where their very lives are at stake simply because of their beliefs.
 
Man that's nuts. I never knew that Well let's do what Jesus would do, set'em on fire and send them to hell!

We already tried that, didn't turn out so well. If you'd like to find out about it look up "The Crusades" in a history book. :lol

Man....people take religion too seriously.

Not necessarily. I mean, looking at Christianity for example, the idea of an eternal afterlife greatly diminishes the purpose of this life. No matter how long we are alive, 50 years, 70 years, 100 years, when you compare that with the infinity of the afterlife you realize this life is infinitely insignificant. Following that logic, you can only underemphasize the importance of religion. I myself am a Christian, and I do take it very seriously, because my life does completely (or rather, should completely) revolve around my system of beliefs.

In most cases, religion tries to explain our, or give us, purpose for being alive, and that should always be taken seriously.

religious governments aren't the best way to go

I also agree. Religious leaders are taught how to teach their religion, not organize governments and create budgets and whatnot.
 
stealth toilet said:
We already tried that, didn't turn out so well. If you'd like to find out about it look up "The Crusades" in a history book.  :lol

I know :( God those were some PARANOID times :) Havent had this much fun since the SALEM WITCH TRAILS! :lol
 
guitarwizard said:
They hate Christian converts as much as we in America hate people who convert to satanism....a lot.

I don't know about that. Even though people who practice satanism or atheism are hated, it still doesn't come close to the hatred that some Islamic fundamentalists have for western culture and religion.

stealth toilet said:
Not necessarily. I mean, looking at Christianity for example, the idea of an eternal afterlife greatly diminishes the purpose of this life. No matter how long we are alive, 50 years, 70 years, 100 years, when you compare that with the infinity of the afterlife you realize this life is infinitely insignificant. Following that logic, you can only underemphasize the importance of religion. I myself am a Christian, and I do take it very seriously, because my life does completely (or rather, should completely) revolve around my system of beliefs.
.

I agree that this life pales in comparison to eternity but I don't see how it diminishes it's purpose, since we still have a chance to either live a good afterlife or a bad one from the choices we make in this life. At least from what I remember according to Christianity and Catholicism.
 
I agree that this life pales in comparison to eternity but I don't see how it diminishes it's purpose

You're right, it was a poor choice of words. What I was trying to illustrate was the point that religion is a very serious thing, and more than that, any belief system is. Whether we are aware of it or not, we all live according to a set of morals, principles, guidelines, etc., (all of which are at the backbone of most religions) and to say that some people take these things "too seriously" seems to suggest that whoever would say that is not fully aware of what they are saying. Let me take an about turn and say that religion (namely Christianity) emphasises the importance of this life as it is the only one we get, and it will have eternal consequences. Which makes it a very serious thing indeed.

I don't know about that. Even though people who practice satanism or atheism are hated, it still doesn't come close to the hatred that some Islamic fundamentalists have for western culture and religion.

First of all, I think it's dangerous to use satanists and atheists in the same context like that, as they are not nearly the same thing. Also, I find the initial statement in which satanists were brought up:
They hate Christian converts as much as we in America hate people who convert to satanism....a lot
to be comparing apples and oranges. However, I will admit I know very little about satanism (the fact that it acknowledges the existence of the devil while at the same time revering him is beyond my comprehension, though I'm assuming there is probably a lot more to it than that) but from what I can tell there is no "hatred" held for satanists as there is for western culture from Islamic Fundamentalists. Although satanists are not exactly thought of by western culture in a positive light, they aren't a threat to our culture. In fact, if satanists worship the Christian devil, they would almost be in accordance with our culture. If they pray for greed, lust, pride, gluttony, etc., then their prayers have practically been answered.

Sorry if I'm getting a little too into this, but religion in general is a bit of a hot button issue with me, as I find that many misconceptions and stigmas about religion exist. I even found myself assuming several things about satanism with little or no factual knowledge to back up those assumptions. So in a discussion such as this I very much get the "treading on thin ice" feeling and I begin to find people making a lot of bold statements that lead me to question what they are based on, or if they are even intended to be so bold.
 
stealth toilet said:
First of all, I think it's dangerous to use satanists and atheists in the same context like that, as they are not nearly the same thing.

I never intended that they are the same or nearly the same, but are basically treated the same by other religions. Im only comparing the feelings people have for them, not the similarities or differences in their beliefs. So I don't see any danger.
 
guitarwizard said:
They hate Christian converts as much as we in America hate people who convert to satanism....a lot.

"We in America hate people who convert to satanism....a lot." is a pretty bold statement. I am not defending that religion (as I don't defend any religion at this time), however, I am defending the right for people to practice what they choose without ignorance. Have you ever really talked to someone who was into satanism? It's not the opposite of christianity, as most christians are taught. It is (to my understanding) more about hedonistic views and personal goals. A former member of this site practices those beliefs. It would be wrong of me not to point out that your statement was made without many facts.

[quote author=megadrive]Man that's nuts. I never knew that Well let's do what Jesus would do, set'em on fire and send them to hell! [/quote]

Since when did Jesus Christ set people on fire and send them to hell. Maybe all that reading of the bible that I have done was misinterpreted. I was pretty darn sure that the coming of the messiah was the grace of god, not the wrath of god... Again, someone needs to do some reading before posting.

[quote author=stealth]Not necessarily. I mean, looking at Christianity for example, the idea of an eternal afterlife greatly diminishes the purpose of this life. No matter how long we are alive, 50 years, 70 years, 100 years, when you compare that with the infinity of the afterlife you realize this life is infinitely insignificant.[/quote]

However, if there is an afterlife, underemphasizing this life does not give people more rights to infringe their beliefs on others. There is importance in living each day as it comes and not planning everything around a single belief. Even if someone had faith that they would be taken care of in retirement does not mean that they should make no preparations for themselves.

"Faith without works" is worthless.

[quote author=megadrive]Havent had this much fun since the SALEM WITCH TRAILS! [/quote]

Look up ergot in relation to the salem witch trials. There's more of an explaination to it than you assume.

[quote author=creepindeth]Even though people who practice satanism or atheism are hated[/quote]

Atheism literally means "no theism", no religious practice. Therefore it is LACK of practice. And, I hope that athiests are not necessarily hated since, as I stated before, people should be free to practice their beliefs as long as they are not causing harm to others. (Read up on John Stewart Mill's liberty limiting principles.)

[quote author=creepindeth]I agree that this life pales in comparison to eternity but I don't see how it diminishes it's purpose, since we still have a chance to either live a good afterlife or a bad one from the choices we make in this life. At least from what I remember according to Christianity and Catholicism.[/quote]

I agree, the chance of eternity should not diminish the importance of this reality, this time and this life.

[quote author=stealth]Whether we are aware of it or not, we all live according to a set of morals, principles, guidelines, etc., (all of which are at the backbone of most religions) and to say that some people take these things "too seriously" seems to suggest that whoever would say that is not fully aware of what they are saying.[/quote]

I currently am not actively practicing any religion, but am a moral person. Religion and morals are not inseparable. Read up on deontology, utilitarianism, consequentialism, virtue ethics, Bentham, John Stewart Mill, Hobbes and Immanual Kant. I've taken a few ethics courses and have to make medical ethical decisions every day in my line of work.

[quote author=stealth]Sorry if I'm getting a little too into this, but religion in general is a bit of a hot button issue with me, as I find that many misconceptions and stigmas about religion exist.[/quote]

I'm glad that you pointed that out. I agree that many stigmas are held in ignorance. Actually, I was once told by a Lutheran (Christian/protistant) pastor that my half caucasion, half pakistanian friend was going to hell since his father was muslim even though his mother was christian. He was brought up learning about both religions, yet after explaining that to the pastor, he replied, "Your friend is going to hell unless he learns the truth." (BV, I won't use names, but you know the pastor, unfortunately.) There is such a strong stigma in many religions that automatically alienates them from eachother. Unfortunately, this brings about immoral behavior among believers of different faiths.

I'd like to see this topic continue in a logical, respectful fashion. No one has really gotten out of line, but please, think about what you say before posting responses on subjects that you know little about (namely faiths other than your own unless you've done some serious study on the topic).
 
I'd like to see this topic continue in a logical, respectful fashion. No one has really gotten out of line, but please, think about what you say before posting responses on subjects that you know little about (namely faiths other than your own unless you've done some serious study on the topic).

I agree. And I have done some seriou study on the topic at hnd. And while I am quick to defend my beliefs, I am slow to pass judgment on others, that is until I have all the facts presented to me.

He was brought up learning about both religions, yet after explaining that to the pastor, he replied, "Your friend is going to hell unless he learns the truth."

I'd like to comment on this. I don't think it was the meaning behind his comment that was wrong, it may have been the delivery. Biblically speaking, he should have said, "If he doesn't know Christ, then your friend will go to hell." But even then, why do people bring out the consequences of a bad decision instead of the benefits of a good decision?? I guess some pastors, or people, are just like that.

We already tried that, didn't turn out so well. If you'd like to find out about it look up "The Crusades" in a history book.

Remember, just because the Crusades were carried out under the banner of Christianity, it wasn't endorsed Biblically. The Church leaders of that time exploited the people who couldn't speak Latin and therefore couldn't read the Bible telling them that the Bible says if you fight a bloody war for the church, then you will take the Heaven Express when you die. Find me a verse that backs that up. Have you read up on those battles? How Crusaders raped and murdered the women, killed the kids that were there, and pillaged the cities?? It's no wonder why Arabs hate Westerners!!

So, in the end, the Crusades were not by definition a Christian led war.
 
@Grindspin...

The point of my statement was not based on the theological beliefs or practices of another religion,but on the hatred of that religion by almost everyone in this nation.Go out in public,and say I practice satanism!!you would then be an outcast to many many people..which is how the Muslims view Christianity..with hatred.
So exactly which facts were missing from my statement?
NONE
 
Guitarwizard, this wasn't supposed to be a call out match. But yes, your statements lack support. Maybe your community isn't tolerant of anyone who isn't anglo-saxon and protistant. Some communities, however, are.

I won't say that it would be a popular thing to say in Fort Wayne, Indiana (or in most of the so-called "bible belt"), however, my time at Indiana University in Bloomington showed me a wide tolerance of many belief systems. Ever had the culture shock of being out of the country and seeing how many differences in cultures, beliefs and day to day life exist?

I do not know how old you are or what your community is like, but, there is a world wider than you're aware of apparently.
 
You do not seem to comprehend...perhaps you need to carfully read my post which you replied to as non factual...the USA is a primarily Christian nation,and we are intolerant of what would seemingly be the antithesis of our religion....the most pagan of pagan religions..satanism.Likewise certain nations of the Muslim persuasion are extremely intolerant of Christianity to the point of killing people simply because they are Christians...I do know how old you are or what your community is like,but tolerance for other religions is not the norm...there is a wider,and much harsher world than you are aware of apparently.Those are the facts..before you say someone is wrong or that their statements lack support perhaps you should at least try to understand what they have said.
 
Actually...I know of nobody personally that would outcast somebody for their religous beliefs, even if they do worship satan. We were taught to be accepting of all, no matter what their beliefs.
 
Back
Top