EGM's breakdown of the pros & cons of DS

Mai Valentine

Moderator
Strengths:
-Plays all old GBA games, which gives it a huge library of favorites right out of the gate
-Cart-based games mean no loading times and a long battery life
-Nintendo has ruled the handheld market for more than 15 years, so they know it better than anyone
-Nintendo makes the best first-party games in the business, and a few million people will buy anything to play a new Pokemon game
-It's possible to play multiplayer games across multiple DSes with only one cart of the game


Weaknesses:
-Front and shoulder buttons are too small (and they don't have the same satisfying give of the GBA's buttons), and the lack of an analog stick is a step backward for 3D gaming
-Cart-based games also mean worse sound and less storage space for things like speech and video
-Big and, well, pretty damn ugly--won't win any beauty contests, unless those "minor tweaks" become major
-The touch screen seems prone to scratches, especially when you're rubbing a stylus over it all day (Nintendo says it is working on a solultion)

Vital Stats

Release Date:
Official: By the end of 2004
Our guess: November 2004

Price:
Official: "Over $99, less than $300"
Our guess: $150

Media:
-DS carts are roughly half the physical size of GBA games--they can hold 1 gigabit (1/14 the capacity of the PSP's media)
-Plays DS and GBA games

Other:
-Up to 16 players can network within a range of at least 30 feet (or more, depending on location) or connect to the Internet via Wi-Fi
-Includes a standard headphone jack and rechargeable battery
-Won't work with GBA-Gamecube link cable for "connectivity"

Out of the 8 people on the staff, only 3 of them thought the DS was better than the PSP.
 
man...

those cons really seem to eat into Nintendo. but then again..... the price is basically going to be half.

I don't know what to think.... :-\


†B†V† :hat
 
I wonder how Nintendo will fair against a major handheld competitor. I mean, most handheld systems have been overshadowed or just crushed by Nintendo.
 
I figure both will sell well. But their ain't now way I'm paying upwards of $300 for a handheld system...I'll buy two DS's before I think about buying a PSP.
One thing I'm starting to wonder about...how small can Nintendo make these carts and realistically expect kids (or thier parents for that matter) not to lose them?
 
Jeepin4Him said:
I figure both will sell well. But their ain't now way I'm paying upwards of $300 for a handheld system...I'll buy two DS's before I think about buying a PSP.
One thing I'm starting to wonder about...how small can Nintendo make these carts and realistically expect kids (or thier parents for that matter) not to lose them?

A long time from now, handheld systems will probablly have a hard drive you just save games to.
 
Jeepin4Him said:
maybe it hasn't been set...but their ain't no way it's gonna be priced as well as the DS. I doubt it'll even be within' $100.

thats my guess.... unless Sony just loses a ton of money on the system as they hope to make it back on the games.


†B†V† :hat
 
Back
Top