I haven't read most of the posts in this topic, so I'm not sure if this issue has been addressed already, so don't mind me if it has.
The person in the first post said that this game was way beyond awesome. I'm a big fan of the Metal Gear Solid series. I think that they're great games, and I'm not surprised that the final MGS game lives up to the hype. From most people, I've only heard good things about it. However, calling it the best game ever seems like an overstatement. From experienced gamers, I have heard that there are areas in the game that could've been improved upon. For example, I hear that the terrain looks bad, and the cinematics are poorly planned (but that person still thinks the story is great).
It's hard to get a good grasp on what this game is like when everybody praises its awesomeness without analyzing its faults. As pointed out by Penny Arcade, people actually got mad that the game got a 9.3 from one website. 9.3 is an awesome score. Just because a game is good doesn't mean it deserves a 10. Perfect scores are given out too easily. 10's should only be given out rarely.
So, let me ask this. Game Informer gave this game a 10 out of 10. Does it really score that high?