Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood

  • Thread starter Thread starter fhqwhgads
  • Start date Start date
fhqwhgads said:
If they wanted to make a good RPG, the last franchise they'd try for is Sonic. They're trying to make a good Sonic game.
Click to expand...

Sonic and the Secret Rings was good. Not great, but good, IMO. No game will beat Sonic Adventure 1 and 2 for me either. 8)
 
Strubes said:
Sonic and the Secret Rings was good. Not great, but good, IMO. No game will beat Sonic Adventure 1 and 2 for me either. 8)
Click to expand...
I hope you didn't say Secret Rings was an RPG.
 
Re-read my post. I would think someone like you would get that the first time through. If not, let's take a look.

Did I say it was an RPG? *checks post*...nope!

Was I responding to you saying "They're trying to make a good Sonic game."? *checks post*...ding ding ding!
 
fhqwhgads said:
If they wanted to make a good RPG, the last franchise they'd try for is Sonic. They're trying to make a good Sonic game.
Click to expand...
Agreed fully and compeltely.  I think making an RPG in a new IP would have expontially increased the game's potential, instead of shackling the game to the corpse that is the Sonic franchise.
 
still does that really means that the games will suck completely?? i mean the gameplay seems to be a fusion of paper mario with some other bioware RPGs
 
I'm kind of confused. Why is everyone so mad that they'd make a Sonic RPG? If it isn't good, or doesn't look good. Don't buy it. :lol
 
Strubes said:
I'm kind of confused. Why is everyone so mad that they'd make a Sonic RPG? If it isn't good, or doesn't look good. Don't buy it. :lol
Click to expand...
Because I love Bioware, as a dev, and I find this game to be nothing but a huge waste of resources. They could be using the thirty some-odd people that are making this game to make sure Dragon Age comes out some time in the next century. But instead they decide to make a game, based around a dying IP, that in no way shape or form fits the kind of game Bioware has proven themselves good at making. I think I have a right to be mad, don't you think?
 
Strubes said:
I'm kind of confused. Why is everyone so mad that they'd make a Sonic RPG? If it isn't good, or doesn't look good. Don't buy it. :lol
Click to expand...
I'm not mad but depressed that a great company like BioWare wasted their time on a Sonic RPG when they could work on KoTOR 3.
 
Homicidal Cherry53 said:
I think I have a right to be mad, don't you think?
Click to expand...

No, because you want them to rush on other games and work hard on them to get them out sooner, correct? And sometimes we wonder why games suck when they're rushed. ::)
 
Strubes said:
No, because you want them to rush on other games and work hard on them to get them out sooner, correct? And sometimes we wonder why games suck when they're rushed. ::)
Click to expand...
The game is suffering from a serious lack of resources. It was announced in 2004, and we've gotten about 20 screenshots since then, no vids, just those screens.

I don't want them to rush it. Not in the slightest. It's just that I want them to actually get serious about developing it, instead of barely making any progress with the game, like they have been recently. This could have happened, had they not decided to syphon off all their resources, towards the Sonic RPG. It is a game that fits them in no possible way shape or form, and is taking away from projects with so much more potential, that seem like they will inevitably stuck on the backburner.

Now I ask again, is it okay for me to angry that they are totally and completely ignoring the game I am anticipating most, in favor of a project that has so much less potential?
 
Homicidal Cherry53 said:
Now I ask again, is it okay for me to angry that they are totally and completely ignoring the game I am anticipating most, in favor of a project that has so much less potential?
Click to expand...

I guess disappointed..but not angry. I'm sure you'll live.

Also, I'm kinda liking how everyone's setting it up for failure. :)
 
Strubes said:
Also, I'm kinda liking how everyone's setting it up for failure. :)
Click to expand...
There are a lot of big hurddles that have to be jumped for this one to be a success, so I think it's fair to be a little spectacle about how good of a game this will turn out to be.
 
Homicidal Cherry53 said:
There are a lot of big hurddles that have to be jumped for this one to be a success, so I think it's fair to be a little spectacle about how good of a game this will turn out to be.
Click to expand...

Alot of games like this are undermined. The more people thinking it's gonna suck is the better for me. I have faith in Bioware.
 
Strubes said:
Re-read my post. I would think someone like you would get that the first time through. If not, let's take a look.

Did I say it was an RPG? *checks post*...nope!

Was I responding to you saying "They're trying to make a good Sonic game."? *checks post*...ding ding ding!
Click to expand...
I read:
If they wanted to make a good RPG, the last franchise they'd try for is Sonic.
Sonic and the Secret Rings was good.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Not to mention, I was talking Bioware RPG's, not SEGA Team classic Sonic.
Strubes said:
No, because you want them to rush on other games and work hard on them to get them out sooner, correct? And sometimes we wonder why games suck when they're rushed. ::)
Click to expand...
Bioware rushes games? Uh huh...
 
fhqwhgads said:
I read
Click to expand...

I guess you didn't. And you only took part of what I responded to. Congrats on misconstruing it.

They're trying to make a good Sonic game.
Click to expand...

That's what I was responding to. You should know this, since it was what I quoted as well in my response.
 
Strubes said:
I guess you didn't. And you only took part of what I responded to. Congrats on misconstruing it.

That's what I was responding to. You should know this, since it was what I quoted as well in my response.
Click to expand...
Yes, that was established the first time you said it, no need to do it again.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top