I like Runescape for a while, but when you died it was nearly impossible to try and recover. They gave you a billion tools on the training island, and if you die, you keep the 3 "strongest", not the most useful. Which actually left me with a bow (with no arrows) and two shields. Yea, let me use those and show the world my 1337 skills.
I eventually made about 5 accounts, until I just gave up, mostly because I could only remember one, which I died on.
Come to think of it, I haven't played Tibia in a long while either. But its a pain either way. If I play on PvP, I get threatned to leave or fear the wrath of a lvl 50 player, or play on Non-Pvp and listen to kids whine and moan all day, not to mention the guy who took my spear (as in stole after I threw it at an enemy) and wouldn't give it back.
Now you see why I don't play online much, I'll just stick with Warcraft 3 now.